1 | Defence attorney Tamara Brady, standing, questions Robert Holmes, top right, the father of James Holmes, on screen, during the sentencing phase of James' trial. |
2 | Centennial, Colorado: He sounded like a proud father leafing through the family album: There's Jimmy with his grandma, kicking a soccer ball, in a taekwondo uniform, holding his new baby sister. |
3 | There's the annual family portrait. |
4 | Mouse ears at Disneyland. |
5 | Boating at Big Bear Lake. |
6 | This week, however, Robert Holmes was narrating a parent's worst nightmare: The story of his son's youth, told at the young man's murder trial in front of the jury that would decide whether his first-born would live or die. |
7 | A memorial along Alameda Avenue, Aurora, to honour the 12 victims of the massacre at a nearby movie theatre three years ago. |
8 | "Jimmy" is James E. Holmes, now 27, who was convicted less than two weeks ago of 165 counts of murder and attempted murder in the 2012 cinema massacre in Aurora, Colorado. |
9 | He killed eight men, three women and a little girl and wounded 70 others, many seriously. |
10 | The verdict means the former neuroscience graduate student could get the death penalty for shooting. |
11 | His parents have sat just a few feet behind him throughout the lengthy trial in Centennial, Colorado. |
12 | They've watched survivors of the grisly shooting describe their horror, heard the families of victims cry, looked at photographs of the bodies their son left strewn across the floor of Theatre 9 of the Century 16 cineplex. |
13 | James Holmes in 2012. |
14 | Defence attorney Tamara Brady: "Is James Holmes your son?" |
15 | Robert Holmes: "Yes he is." |
16 | Brady: "Have you been here throughout this trial?" |
17 | James Holmes in 2013. |
18 | Holmes: "Yes, I have." |
19 | Brady: "Has it been hard for you to listen to?" |
20 | Holmes: "Yes. It's been a very difficult experience... " |
21 | Brady: "Do you still love him?" |
22 | Holmes: "Yes, I do." |
23 | Brady: "Why?" |
24 | Holmes: "He's my son. We got along pretty well. He's an excellent kid." |
25 | The death penalty trial of the Aurora gunman is nearing the end of the so-called mitigation phase - the time when defense attorneys are trying to convince jurors that one of the deadliest mass shooters in American history is a human being. |
26 | The defense wants mercy for Holmes, a sentence of life in prison without possibility of parole rather than execution. |
27 | For the last week, a parade of school friends, college friends, church friends and elementary school teachers has testified that Holmes was quiet, socially awkward, maybe withdrawn, but also very smart and completely nonviolent. |
28 | They talked about his love of video games and his volunteer work at a Mexican orphanage. |
29 | They called him "Jimmy." |
30 | It is a childhood nickname only witnesses may use in court, as per the order of Judge Carlos A. Samour Jr. Defense attorneys call him Mr. Holmes. |
31 | Prosecutors began trial referring to him with a disdainful "that guy," but have since settled on "the defendant." |
32 | On Tuesday morning, former neighbor Lori Bidwell talked about how "Jimmy was very shy." |
33 | His second-grade teacher, Ann Hestand, said, "I cared for him in 1996, and I still care for Jimmy." |
34 | Fifth-grade teacher Paul Henry Karrer said the defendant - "he's Jimmy to me" - was "like a renaissance child." |
35 | That child grew into a deeply uncommunicative young man. |
36 | Once he went off to college, James Holmes was someone who largely interacted with his parents via email and text, his father testified. |
37 | Holmes gave his parents no inkling until it was too late that he had found and lost a girlfriend, dropped out of graduate school, amassed an arsenal, the father said. |
38 | His psychiatrist at the University of Colorado called Robert and Arlene Holmes in mid-June 2012, concerned about their son's behaviour. |
39 | On July 4, they decided to make the trip from their home in San Diego to check on his welfare. |
40 | They never got there. |
41 | On July 20, James Holmes wrapped himself in protective armor, grabbed his weapons and shot up the Aurora multiplex. |
42 | Brady: "Assuming Mr. Holmes stays in jail or prison, do you and your wife intend to try and visit him if he will let you see him?" |
43 | Robert Holmes: "Yes." |
44 | Brady: "Will you write him letters?" |
45 | Holmes: "Yes." |
46 | Brady: "Will you always do that?" |
47 | The trial is in the punishment phase, when it will be determined if Holmes should be put to death or serve a mandatory life sentence with no possibility of parole. |